The articlegameplay, story, development, reception
Gameplay
Quest for the Rings is ideally played with three players. One player takes the role of Ring Master and hides ten ring tokens and a number of monster tokens underneath 23 castle tokens scattered around the game board. The other two players move together across the game board traveling from castle to castle. When the players reach a castle token, they flip it up to reveal the tokens underneath.
The underside of the castle token contains a symbol representing one of four possible dungeon types. The castle token might also hide a ring token and possibly one of two different monster tokens. Players then use a keyboard overlay to input the dungeon symbol and the tokens found underneath into the keyboard.
Development
The game concept was first pitched in a meeting between Mike Staup, vice president of game development at Magnavox, and Ed Averett who had designed many previous Odyssey² titles. Magnavox had received a lot of feedback from console owning families that enjoyed using the system as a communal activity. Fathers were looking for games that their children could not beat them at and involved a little bit more strategy. Averett found the limited size of the standard 2 KB cartridges to be too restrictive to implement complicated strategy. The introduction of board game elements was intended to solve this problem.
Quest for the Rings was designed by Averett, who handled the video game elements, and Steve Lehner, who handled the board game elements including the mylar sheet used as an overlay for the Odyssey²'s keyboard. Lehner and artist Rob Bradford had previously worked on the materials and packaging for the Magnavox Odyssey and Odyssey² through their marketing firm Bradford/Cout Design out of Skokie, Illinois. According to Lehner, the two of them were looking to go beyond the arcade ports and sports simulations that dominated the console market at the time. According to Averett, attempting to combine video games and board games gave them direction.
Reception
Quest for the Rings was favorably reviewed by Video magazine in its "Arcade Alley" column where it was described as "an instant classic" with "'super hit' stamped all over it in gold letters". The combination of video game and board game elements was considered to be particularly well conceived, producing what the reviewers called "a vigorous new hybrid unlike anything ever seen in home arcading." It was awarded "Most Innovative Game" at the 3rd annual Arkie Awards where it was described as "stand[ing] out like Charlene Tilton at a spinster's convention". Arkie Award judges commented that "every element of Quest is absolutely first-rate from the animation of the various creatures to the clean rules", and the game was additionally awarded an Honorable Mention in the category of "Best Audio-Visual Effects". Electronic Games, edited by the writers of "Arcade Alley" (Bill Kunkel and Arnie Katz), selected the game to be a part of its "Videogame Hall of Fame."
George Sullivan in his 1982 book How to Win at Video Games: A Complete Guide said the graphics were "so exciting that many new players surrender outright the first few times they play, just to be able to watch the monsters romp about the screen." JoyStik magazine liked the packaging and graphics and said it was "well worth its steep price." In October 1982, The Logical Gamer ranked it as "one of the best [fantasy role-playing games] available for any system to date" and "the best [game] that Odyssey has ever produced." David Lubar of Creative Computing was more critical of the game, complimenting the packaging and illustrations but seeing it as "a good idea that, given the limitations of the Odyssey, just doesn't quite make it as a game." He complained about the "slowness and low resolution of the graphics" but liked how the game lived up to the spirit of Dungeons and Dragons by being a cooperative game.









