The articlegameplay, story, development, reception
Reception
MLB The Show 17 received "generally favorable" reviews from critics, according to review aggregator Metacritic.
Ray Carsillo from Electronic Gaming Monthly enjoyed the game, giving a score of 9/10. Carsillo said The Show 17 added depth onto Franchise and Road to The Show modes "sets a new pinnacle for the franchise". He also praised how the game looked, with smoother animations, new character face models, and three brand-new presentation packages. His only negatives revolve around some online issues and glitches that still continue to plague the series at launch.
Andrew Reiner of Game Informer gave the game an overall score of 9 out 10 saying "MLB The Show 17 is an ambitious game that tries to dazzle players with new avenues of play and a story, but is at its best on the field, where the action has never looked or played better."
Richard Wakeling from GameSpot gave the game an 8 out of 10 and praised the gameplay stating "the action on the field has never been better, with smarter fielding AI, and enhanced ball physics that bring the hitting to life." Wakeling criticized the commentary as "stilted" and noted the game had a few "blemishes lurking throughout," but found those problems detracted little from the overall experience saying the product overall "is America's National Pastime at its best".
GamesRadar's Ben Wilson gave the game a final score of 4 out of 5. Wilson enjoyed the game's polish and controls stating "Plays, looks and feels just like real baseball" and that the "Retooled ball physics and myriad new animations are the main differentiator from MLB 16, with outfielders taking more varied angles to cut off line drive doubles, and more realistic spin effects." Some of Wilson's criticisms involve that any of the game's modes "requires significant time commitment, even with speedier options" and that "Last year's online woes remain its Achilles heel".
Caley Roark gave the game a positive review for IGN. He scored it a 9.5/10, praised the overall presentation and gameplay, and stated: "Overall, MLB The Show 17 builds on last year's version, which many cited as the best in the series, by adding some key features and improvements. Most notable are increased hit variety, MLB Network integration, and the RTTS documentary. All of these additions make the game feel more like real baseball. This authenticity makes games more fun to play, as it's easier than ever to become invested in every pitch."
Polygon's Owen S. Good awarded the game an 8 out of 10, concluding: "MLB The Show 17 continues one of the longest-running successes in sports video gaming, and it's not a regression. But its advances sound a lot bigger on paper than they are in practice." Good praised the gameplay calling it "wonderfully varied" with pitching mechanics that "just feels stronger". One negative aspect of his review involves repetition in its presentation, saying its "MLB The Show's biggest weakness".
The game won the award for "Best Player Career Mode" at Game Informer's 2017 Sports Game of the Year Awards, and was nominated for "Sports Game of the Year" at the 21st Annual D.I.C.E. Awards, and for "Game, Franchise Sports" at the 17th Annual National Academy of Video Game Trade Reviewers Awards.





























